Global Best Practice Supplier Maturity Ratings | Качество и Жизнь

Global Best Practice Supplier Maturity Ratings

V.V. Tokarev, Moscow Aviation Institute (NRU); Moscow
A.R. Deniskina, candidate of technical sciences, associate professor, Moscow Aviation Institute (NRU); Moscow
The paper considers issues of evaluating the maturity of suppliers based on the application of best international practices that contribute to the identification of possible risks at the early stages of contractual relations, their prevention and exclusion.
Keywords: supplier maturity, checklist, audit automation, quality management.
1.   Deniskin  Yu.I.,  Dubrovin  A.V., Podkolzin V.G. Quality management of the life cycle processes of innovative products based on a computer-based quality management system. Transactions of Moscow aviation institute. 2017, No. 95. Available at:
2.   Tokarev V.V., Letchford L.N., Doroshenko N.V. Quality assurance of purchased products based on suppliers’ audits. Methods of quality management. Standards and quality. Moscow, 2019. 68 p.
3.   Deniskin Yu.I., Dubrovin A.V., Podkolzin V.G. Quality management of the life cycle processes of innovative products based on a computer-based quality management system. Transactions of Moscow Aviation Institute. 2017, No. 95. Available at:
4.   Redko A.O., Smerchinskaya S.O., Yashina N.P. Aggregation of preferences with variable importance of criteria. Proceedings of the Moscow Aviation Institute. 2016, No. 85. Available at:
5.   Malykhina M.A. The interaction system of quality management and marketing management in a modern organization. Transactions of Moscow Aviation Institute. 2015, No. 79. Available at:
6.   Procurement and qualification of suppliers in Siemens. Siemens AG. 2013. 7 p.
7.   Solovieva I.A., Soloviev D.S., Litovka Yu.V., Korobova I.L. Modification of the method of analyzing hierarchies to increase the objectivity of decisions. Transactions of Moscow Aviation Institute. 2018, No. 98. Available at:
8.   The organization’s standard «Supplier evaluation audit», approved by order of the General Director of UAC-Purchases LLC dated 05.11.2015, No. 302. 100 p.
9.   Kondrashin M.A., Arsenov O.Yu., Kozlov I.V. Application of virtualization technology and cloud computing in the construction of complex distributed modeling systems. Transactions of Moscow Aviation Institute. 2016, No. 89. Available at:
10. ABB Supplier Requirements, 9AKK102949 ABB Supplier Requirements, revision C. 9 p.
11. ABB Supplier Quality Guidelines. ABB Inc. Robotics N.A., Eighth Edition. November 2012, Rev 8. 20 p. 3.03.P01.W01.
12. SCREQ-001 «Process Requirements in Developing Excellence», revision F. October 15, 2010. 39 p.
13. SAFRAN  GRF-0033  «Requirements Compliance Matrix». Edition 0, revision 4, date of last revision 14.01.2014.
14. Procedure N GRP-0087 «SAFe – Safran requirements to Supplier». Index: Issue: 4 Revision: 1. Date of last revision: 26.06.2013. 104 p.
15. Dickson G.W. An Analysis of vendor selection systems and decisions. Journal of supply chain management. 1966. 92 p.
16. S. Hossein Cheraghi, Mohammad Dadashzadeh, Muthu Subramanian. Critical Success Factors For Supplier Selection: An Update. Journal of applied business research. 2004. pp. 91–108.
17. Sivadass Thiruchelvam, John Tookey. Evolving Trends of Supplier Selection Criteria and Methods, S. Thiruchelvam and J.E. Tookey. International Journal of automotive and mechanical engineering. July 2011. 454 p.
18. Supplier Selection & Capabilities Assessment (SSCA)-Section 4.1. Available at:
19. Product performance detailed assessment checklists user guide. 2014. Available at: 4.2.
20. Sub-tier supplier control management, SCMH Section 4.4.2. 2014. Available at: Section 4.4.
21. Aalborg University – Department of business and management. Master Thesis. Supplier Management at Siemens Wind Power. Nicoleta Roxana Turcitu. Supervisor: Romeo V Turcan. 2015. 80 p.
22. SCM STAR supplier information package April 2017. Available at:
23. Supplier quality manual. Valeo Siemens eAutomotive. SQ 2107. 36 p.
24. Klarjic P. Purchasing must become supply management. Harvard business review. 1983. 560 p.
25. Alstom thermal power supplier quality manual POWER-Q-MSM-002 – Revision B – December 2014. 44 p.
DOI: 10.34214/2312-5209-2020-25-1-66-75

Back to top